Guide
How to choose a therapist
Last updated: 4 September 2026
If you're reading this, there's a good chance you're thinking about starting therapy, perhaps for the first time. That's no small thing. Admitting that something isn't quite right and deciding to do something about it is a real first step.
Choosing a therapist can feel overwhelming. There are a lot of profiles and it's easy to get stuck not knowing where to start. That's exactly why we built our Get Shortlist tool, to take some of the guesswork out of it. So whether you use that, or you'd rather browse and choose yourself, here's what's worth thinking about.
Work out what you need
Before anything else, try to get clear on what's going on for you. Is it anxiety, depression or something harder to put a name to? Maybe it's your relationships or how you see yourself. You don't need a diagnosis. A rough sense of what you want to work on is enough to guide your search.
Some therapists specialize in particular areas. Others work more generally. If you're not sure what you need, ask. A good therapist will tell you honestly what they can and can't help with.
Think about what makes you comfortable
Therapy works best when you feel safe enough to talk, so the relationship matters just as much as the credentials. A few questions worth thinking about:
- Would you rather talk from home or in person somewhere else?
- Do you feel more at ease with someone who listens quietly or someone more direct?
- Would it help to see someone who shares your background or lived experience?
There's no right answer to any of these. It's about what works for you.
Look beyond the letters
Every therapist listed on Men's Therapy Hub holds a current state license, or is in supervised practice toward one. That means they've completed the training, passed the exams, and follow a code of ethics. So legitimacy isn't something you need to worry about here. They've already been vetted.
What's worth your attention instead is how they work. What kind of therapy do they offer? What do they sound like in their profile? Would you feel able to talk to them without being judged?
Some therapists work in a more reflective, insight-based way. Others are more practical and strategy-focused. Neither is better. It's about what speaks to you.
Test the waters
Most therapists offer a free 15 to 20 minute consultation call. Use it to get a feel for how they work.A few good questions to bring:
- Have you worked with men facing similar issues?
- What does your approach involve?
- How do your sessions usually run?
Pay attention to how you feel during the conversation, not just the answers. Do you feel heard? Do you feel safe? That gut feeling matters more than you might think.
Check the money side early
If you plan to use insurance, filter for therapists who take your plan, or ask whether they provide a superbill you can submit for out-of-network reimbursement. Many therapists also offer a sliding scale. It's a normal question to ask on the first call.
It's okay to change your mind
You might not get it right the first time. That's normal. If something feels off or you're not seeing progress, it's fine to try someone else. You're allowed to find someone who actually fits. Therapy is about you, not about sticking with the first person you meet.
You don't have to have all the answers. You just have to start.
"Starting therapy means you're ready to stop carrying everything on your own. Finding the right therapist can take a little time, but it's worth it in the end. The right person can help you make sense of things, see your patterns more clearly and move forward with more clarity." Chris Hemmings, founder of Men's Therapy Hub
Let's find someone who fits.
Use our 'get shortlist' tool and answer three quick questions. We'll narrow the directory down to the men most likely to be a good fit.